From a past girlfriend I ended up with a nice sex toy collection, and a little fetish for toys. I've got some really nice pyrex dildos and some wilder stuff.
Previously I had a girl that was into them, but only if they were brand-spankin new (like that we would have bought together). She had a major hang-up over toys that had been in prior use. I understand the hang-up, but need some advice on getting around it with new girls. I don't want to have to re-buy some of this stuff every time I have a new girl coming through
Any thoughts on getting new girls over the hump when it comes to my personal toy collection?

put a condom on them, seems like the best thing

some of the stuff can get pricey...but a small price to pay for a great hobby.
Consider buying new toys just the price of doing business.
And,...you won`t have to go thru any explanations or turn-offs and health issues.

__________________
"Act surprised...Show concern...Deny...Deny...Deny".

Let her see you take them out of the dishwasher so she knows they're clean? Of course then she may never eat at your house again.
lucifer

Better idea is wash them in the sink infront of her.
Even though it does practically nothing, it frames it up as being 100% clean.
If she complains, say your hands and lips have gone through the same process in the first place.
If she presists, put a connie on them.
Process with two levels of accuracy, you can't do wrong there.