Just field tested the "We should get a divorce, I'm just too naughty for you"

And it blew up in my face LOL. I tried on three different girls I have been txting from POF, have built some comfort, and have made a sexual frame of differing degrees with all. So far all think I am being serious, and I have had to reframe by saying "and here I thought you had a sense of humor." Am I supposed to put a smiley after it? I was under the impression its supposed to qualify them.