I use that line all the time. The fact that she responded means she's asking you to beat her in combat. That opener leads to duelling. Plow through, stick with the break up theme. That's how I work that opener, it's so money. Say things like "i admire your fortitude but i can't go on being treated like a sex object." If she really hated you for using that line, she wouldn't have responded.
Women have two types of toys: teddy bears and vibrators. Teddy bears are for when they are emotional and want to watch romcoms, and vibrators for when they want to get off. What toy are you?