www.calicojacksnyc.com
Calico Jacks is a great place for college students and recent college grads. I've had an awesome time every time I go there and they always have drink specials ($20 for two hours of drinking, stuff like that). Lots of ladies and a lot of places to move your target after you open them. I made out with a girl the last time I was there.
McFadden's is right next door and is very good as well.
P.S. - If I go into that place and hear any of Mystery's gambits I will make sure before the end of the night to come up to you and call you out on it while your HB isn't around.